Tirmidhi 2
Wudu of the believer — Tirmidhi 2
Bashhar Awwad writes hasan sahih — Tirmidhi’s own dialect. Shakir and Albani simply say sahih. Same sitting; two ways to name the strength.
Opening the book…
Open Tirmidhi’s gradesal-Tirmidhi
مُحَمَّدُ بْنُ عِيسَى التِّرْمِذِي
209–279 AH
209–279 AH. He heard the Six’s generation, wrote a Jami that cites the fuqaha, and told you what he thought of each chain.
The chain held for him. He may add “and this is the practice of the people of knowledge.”
Usable, with a lighter man. This is the rank he made famous — a step that is not daif and not the peak.
Only one road. Not a wound by itself. A thiqah gharib can still be sahih; a lonely weak road is not.
The debated stamp. Often: one hasan road plus a sahih road; or hasan rising toward sahih; or two critics split. He refused to flatten it.
Sound enough, and still only one road. The Jami is teaching the tree, not hiding it.
Shakir, Albani, Bashhar Awwad, Zubair Ali Zai re-grade the same reports. Disagreement on Tirmidhi 3 and 4 is the method working.
Tirmidhi 2
Bashhar Awwad writes hasan sahih — Tirmidhi’s own dialect. Shakir and Albani simply say sahih. Same sitting; two ways to name the strength.
Opening the book…
Open Tirmidhi’s grades